SwimAnalytics vs Sauran Aikace-aikacen Iyo - Kwatancin Fasali
Yadda SwimAnalytics ke kwatanta da Strava, TrainingPeaks, Final Surge, da sauran dandamali na bin diddigin iyo
Me yasa Iyo Yana Buƙatar Nazarin Musamman
Aikace-aikacen lafiya na gaba ɗaya kamar Strava da TrainingPeaks suna yin kyau a hawan keke da gudu, amma iyo yana buƙatar ma'auni daban-daban. Critical Swim Speed (CSS), yankunan horo na sauri, da ilimin bugun ba a tallafa musu yadda ya kamata a cikin dandamali masu yawa na wasanni. An gina SwimAnalytics musamman don iyo, tare da ma'auni waɗanda aka ƙera don masu iyo na wuraren iyo da ruwa mai buɗewa.
Taƙaitaccen Bayanin Kwatancin
| Fasali | SwimAnalytics | Strava | TrainingPeaks | Final Surge |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gwajin CSS & Yankuna | ✅ Tallafin asali | ❌ A'a | ⚠️ Hannu kawai | ⚠️ Hannu kawai |
| Ƙididdigewar sTSS Na Iyo | ✅ Mai sarrafa kansa | ❌ Babu TSS na iyo | ✅ E (yana buƙatar premium) | ✅ E |
| PMC (CTL/ATL/TSB) | ✅ An haɗa kyauta | ❌ A'a | ✅ Premium kawai ($20/mo) | ✅ Premium ($10/mo) |
| Yankunan Horo Na Sauri | ✅ Yankuna 7, tushen CSS | ❌ Yankuna na gama-gari | ⚠️ Saitin hannu | ⚠️ Saitin hannu |
| Haɗin Apple Watch | ✅ ta Apple Health | ✅ Asali | ✅ ta Garmin/Wahoo | ✅ ta shigo da su |
| Nazarin Ilimin Bugun | ✅ DPS, SR, SI | ⚠️ Tushe | ⚠️ Tushe | ⚠️ Tushe |
| Fasalolin Matakin Kyauta | Gwajin kwana 7, sannan $3.99/mo | ✅ Kyauta (iyakantaccen nazari) | ⚠️ Ƙayyadaddun sosai | ⚠️ Gwajin kwana 14 |
| Tallafin Wasanni Masu Yawa | ❌ Iyo-kawai | ✅ Duk wasanni | ✅ Duk wasanni | ✅ Duk wasanni |
| Fasalolin Jama'a | ❌ A'a | ✅ Mai girma | ⚠️ Koci-dan wasa kawai | ⚠️ Iyakantacce |
SwimAnalytics vs Strava
Abin Da Strava Ya Yi Da Kyau
- Fasalolin jama'a: Ƙungiyoyi, sassan, yabo, abincin aiki
- Bin diddigin wasanni masu yawa: Gudu, hawan keke, iyo, tafiya, da sauransu
- Matakin kyauta: Fasaloli masu karimci kyauta don masu motsa jiki na yau da kullun
- Babban tushen masu amfani: Haɗu da miliyoyin masu motsa jiki a duniya
- Haɗin Apple Watch: Daidaitawa kai tsaye daga motsa jiki
Abin Da SwimAnalytics Ya Yi Da Kyau
- Ma'auni na musamman na iyo: CSS, sTSS, yankunan sauri waɗanda aka ƙera don wuraren iyo
- Nazarin nauyin horo: An haɗa CTL/ATL/TSB (Strava ba shi da wannan)
- sTSS mai sarrafa kansa: Babu shigar bayanai da hannu, an ƙididdige daga CSS + sauri
- Ilimin bugun: DPS, mitar bugun, bin diddigin figitin bugun
- Yankunan horo: Yankuna 7 na sauri na sirri dangane da ilimin halittar ku
Hukunci: SwimAnalytics vs Strava
Yi amfani da Strava idan: Kuna son fasalolin jama'a, bin diddigin wasanni masu yawa, ko bin diddigin kyauta na yau da kullun. Strava yana da kyau don rubuta motsa jiki da haɗawa da abokai.
Yi amfani da SwimAnalytics idan: Kuna da gaske game da aikin iyo kuma kuna son yankuna masu tushen CSS, sTSS mai sarrafa kansa, da sarrafa nauyin horo (CTL/ATL/TSB). Strava ba ya ƙididdige TSS na iyo ko bayar da ma'aunin PMC.
Yi amfani da duka: Masu iyo da yawa suna amfani da Strava don raba jama'a da SwimAnalytics don bin diddigin aiki. Suna haɗuwa da juna sosai.
SwimAnalytics vs TrainingPeaks
Abin Da TrainingPeaks Ya Yi Da Kyau
- PMC mai cikakkiya: Ma'auni na masana'antu na jadawalin CTL/ATL/TSB
- ɗakin Motsa Jiki: Dubban tsararrun motsa jiki
- Haɗin koci: Dandali na ƙwararrun koci-dan wasa
- Horon wasanni masu yawa: Mai da hankali kan triathlon tare da wasanni uku duka
- Nazari mai ƙarfi: Ƙarfi, yankunan bugun zuciya don keke/gudu
Abin Da SwimAnalytics Ya Yi Da Kyau
- Gwajin CSS mai sarrafa kansa: Na'urar ƙididdigewa ta CSS da aka gina tare da samar da yankuna
- An haɗa PMC don iyo: TrainingPeaks yana buƙatar $20/mo Premium don PMC
- Sauƙaƙan haɗin kai: SwimAnalytics yana mai da hankali kan iyo, ba mai ɗaukar nauyi ba
- Apple Watch na asali: Daidaitawa kai tsaye ta Apple Health (babu buƙatar Garmin)
- Ƙaramin farashi: $3.99/mo vs $20/mo don TrainingPeaks Premium
Hukunci: SwimAnalytics vs TrainingPeaks
Yi amfani da TrainingPeaks idan: Kai dan wasan triathlon ne mai horo don abubuwan wasanni masu yawa, kuna da koci da ke amfani da TrainingPeaks, ko kuna buƙatar tsararrun motsa jiki na keke/gudu. TrainingPeaks yana yin kyau don babban horon triathlon.
Yi amfani da SwimAnalytics idan: Kai mai iyo ne (ba dan wasan triathlon ba) ko kuna son ma'aunin musamman na iyo ba tare da biyan $20/mo ba. SwimAnalytics yana bayar da CTL/ATL/TSB da ƙididdigewar sTSS don farashi 80% kaɗan fiye da TrainingPeaks Premium.
Babban bambanci: TrainingPeaks shine wasanni masu yawa tare da fasalolin koyarwa; SwimAnalytics shine iyo-kawai tare da tallafin CSS na asali da samun damar PMC mai rahusa.
SwimAnalytics vs Final Surge
Abin Da Final Surge Ya Yi Da Kyau
- Dandali na koci: An ƙera don dangantakar koci-dan wasa
- Tallafin TSS: Ana samun ƙididdigewar TSS na iyo
- Wasanni masu yawa: Iyo, gudu, hawan keke, ƙarfi
- Tsare motsa jiki: Tsare-tsaren horo na tushen kalanda
- Kayan aiki na sadarwa: Saƙon koci a cikin aikace-aikacen
Abin Da SwimAnalytics Ya Yi Da Kyau
- Gwajin CSS na asali: Na'urar ƙididdigewa da aka gina, ba shigar hannu ba
- sTSS mai sarrafa kansa: An ƙididdige daga bayanan Apple Watch, babu rubuta
- Hankali kan ɗan wasa ɗaya: An ƙera don masu iyo masu koyarwa da kansu
- Haɗin Apple Watch: Daidaitawar aikace-aikacen Lafiya mara lahani
- Iyo na musamman: Ba a narke ta fasalolin wasanni masu yawa ba
Hukunci: SwimAnalytics vs Final Surge
Yi amfani da Final Surge idan: Kuna da koci wanda ke amfani da Final Surge, ko kuna koyar da masu motsa jiki. Final Surge dandali ne na koyarwa da farko, aikace-aikacen dan wasa na biyu.
Yi amfani da SwimAnalytics idan: Kai mai koyarwa da kanka ne kuma kana son nazari mai sarrafa kansa. SwimAnalytics yana buƙatar sifili na rubuta hannu—komai yana daidaitawa daga Apple Watch kai tsaye.
Babban bambanci: Final Surge yana mai da hankali kan koci; SwimAnalytics yana mai da hankali kan dan wasa tare da hankali kan sarrafa kansa.
Abin Da Ke Sa SwimAnalytics Ya Bambanta
1. Tallafin CSS Na Aji Na Farko
SwimAnalytics shine aikace-aikacen kawai tare da na'urar ƙididdigewa ta gwajin CSS na asali. Shigar da lokutan ku na 400m da 200m, nan da nan samu:
- Saurin CSS (misali, 1:49/100m)
- Yankuna 7 na horo na sirri
- Ƙididdigewar sTSS mai sarrafa kansa don duk motsa jiki
- Nazarin motsa jiki na tushen yankuna
Masu gasa: Suna buƙatar saitin yankunan hannu ko ba sa tallafa wa yankunan iyo kwata-kwata.
2. sTSS Mai Sarrafa Kansa Don Iyo
Yawancin aikace-aikacen suna buƙatar shigar TSS da hannu ko ba sa ƙididdige TSS na iyo kwata-kwata. SwimAnalytics:
- Yana ƙididdige sTSS kai tsaye daga kowane motsa jiki na Apple Watch
- Yana amfani da CSS + saurin motsa jiki don tantance Intensity Factor
- Babu buƙatar rubuta hannu—saita CSS sau ɗaya, manta game da shi
Strava: Ba ya ƙididdige TSS na iyo. TrainingPeaks: Yana buƙatar $20/mo Premium. Final Surge: Yana buƙatar shigar hannu.
3. Samun Damar PMC Mai Rahusa
Performance Management Chart (CTL/ATL/TSB) shine mai mahimmanci don sarrafa nauyin horo, amma mai tsada a cikin dandamali na wasu:
- SwimAnalytics: An haɗa don $3.99/mo
- TrainingPeaks: Yana buƙatar $20/mo Premium ($240/shekara)
- Strava: Ba a samu a kowane farashi
- Final Surge: $10/mo premium ($120/shekara)
SwimAnalytics yana bayar da CTL/ATL/TSB a farashi 80% kaɗan fiye da TrainingPeaks.
4. Apple Watch Na Asali
SwimAnalytics yana daidaitawa kai tsaye tare da Apple Health—ba a buƙatar agogon Garmin ba:
- Yana aiki tare da kowane Apple Watch (Series 2+)
- Shigar motsa jiki kai tsaye daga aikace-aikacen Lafiya
- Sauri lap-by-lap, ƙidayar bugun, SWOLF
- Babu buƙatar ƙarin kayan aiki
TrainingPeaks: Yana buƙatar na'urar Garmin/Wahoo ($200-800). Strava: Yana aiki tare da Apple Watch amma yana rasa nazarin iyo.
5. Hankali Kan Iyo-Kawai
Aikace-aikacen wasanni masu yawa suna ƙoƙarin yin komai, yawanci suna yin iyo da ƙasa. SwimAnalytics an gina shi na musamman don iyo:
- An ƙera haɗin kai a kewaye da tsarin aikin horon wuraren iyo
- Ma'auni masu dacewa ga masu iyo (CSS, sTSS, ilimin bugun)
- Babu ɓata fasali daga bin diddigin keke/gudu/tafiya
- Ana mai da hankali sabuntawa kan inganta iyo
Kwatancin Farashi (Kudin Shekara)
SwimAnalytics
- ✅ Gwajin CSS & yankuna
- ✅ Ƙididdigewar sTSS mai sarrafa kansa
- ✅ PMC (CTL/ATL/TSB)
- ✅ Ilimin bugun (DPS, SR, SI)
- ✅ Daidaitawar Apple Watch
- ❌ Wasanni masu yawa
- ❌ Fasalolin jama'a
Strava
- ✅ Bin diddigin motsa jiki na asali
- ✅ Fasalolin jama'a (ƙungiyoyi, yabo)
- ✅ Tallafin wasanni masu yawa
- ❌ Babu tallafin CSS
- ❌ Babu TSS na iyo
- ❌ Babu PMC
- ❌ Babu nazarin iyo
TrainingPeaks
- ✅ PMC (CTL/ATL/TSB)
- ✅ Ƙididdigewar TSS
- ✅ Nazarin wasanni masu yawa
- ✅ Dandali na koci
- ⚠️ Babu gwajin CSS na asali
- ⚠️ Saitin yankunan hannu
- 💰 5x kudin SwimAnalytics
Final Surge
- ✅ Bin diddigin TSS
- ✅ Kayan aikin koci-dan wasa
- ✅ Wasanni masu yawa
- ⚠️ Shigar sTSS da hannu
- ⚠️ Babu gwajin CSS na asali
- 💰 2.5x kudin SwimAnalytics
💡 Nazarin Farashi-Fa'ida
Idan kai mai iyo-kawai ne: SwimAnalytics yana bayar da PMC + sTSS + yankunan CSS don $48/shekara. TrainingPeaks yana caji $240/shekara don fasaloli masu kama (5x tsada).
Idan kai dan wasan triathlon ne: Yi la'akari da TrainingPeaks ko Final Surge don tallafin wasanni masu yawa. SwimAnalytics shine iyo-kawai kuma ba zai bin diddigin horon keke/gudu ba.
Wa Ya Kamata Ya Yi Amfani Da SwimAnalytics?
✅ Cikakke Don:
- Masu iyo masu gasa: Masters, rukuni na shekaru, masu motsa jiki na kwaleji masu mai da hankali kan aikin iyo
- Masu motsa jiki masu koyarwa da kansu: Masu iyo masu sarrafa horon su ba tare da koci ba
- Masu horo masu tushen bayanai: Masu motsa jiki waɗanda ke son yankunan CSS, sTSS, da ma'aunin PMC
- Masu amfani da Apple Watch: Masu iyo waɗanda suka riga suna amfani da Apple Watch don bin diddigin wuraren iyo
- Masu motsa jiki masu la'akari da kasafin kuɗi: Suna son fasalolin PMC ba tare da kuɗin $20/mo premium ba
⚠️ Ba Mafi Kyau Ba Don:
- Masu wasan triathlon: Suna buƙatar bin diddigin wasanni masu yawa (yi amfani da TrainingPeaks ko Final Surge)
- Masu motsa jiki na jama'a: Suna son ƙungiyoyi, yabo, abincin aiki (yi amfani da Strava)
- Masu motsa jiki da aka koyar: Koci ya riga yana amfani da dandali na TrainingPeaks ko Final Surge
- Masu iyo na yau da kullun: Ba su da sha'awar CSS, sTSS, ko nazarin nauyin horo
- Masu amfani da Garmin-kawai: Ba su da Apple Watch (SwimAnalytics yana buƙatar iOS)
Tambayoyin Da Aka Yawan Tambaya
Zan iya amfani da SwimAnalytics DA Strava/TrainingPeaks?
E—masu iyo da yawa suna amfani da duka. Yi amfani da SwimAnalytics don nazarin aiki (CSS, sTSS, PMC) da Strava don raba jama'a da rubutun wasanni masu yawa. Suna haɗuwa da juna sosai.
Shin SwimAnalytics yana aiki tare da agogon Garmin?
A'a. SwimAnalytics yana daidaitawa ta Apple Health, wanda ke buƙatar Apple Watch. Idan kuna amfani da Garmin, yi la'akari da TrainingPeaks ko Final Surge maimakon haka.
Me yasa SwimAnalytics ke da rahusa sosai fiye da TrainingPeaks?
SwimAnalytics shine iyo-kawai, ba wasanni masu yawa ba. Ta hanyar mai da hankali musamman kan iyo, muna guje wa rikitarwa da farashin ababen more rayuwa na tallafa wa ma'aunin ƙarfin keke, motsin gudu, dandamalin koci, da sauransu. Wannan yana ba mu damar bayar da PMC + sTSS a farashi 80% kaɗan.
Idan ni dan wasan triathlon ne—shin ya kamata in yi amfani da SwimAnalytics?
Wataƙila ba a matsayin babban aikace-aikacen ku ba. Masu wasan triathlon suna amfana daga dandamali na wasanni masu yawa kamar TrainingPeaks waɗanda ke bin diddigin keke, gudu, da iyo tare. Duk da haka, wasu masu wasan triathlon suna amfani da SwimAnalytics don nazarin iyo na musamman (yankunan CSS) da TrainingPeaks don gabaɗayan nauyin horo.
Shin SwimAnalytics yana da matakin kyauta?
SwimAnalytics yana bayar da gwajin kyauta na kwana 7 tare da cikakkun fasaloli (gwajin CSS, sTSS, PMC). Bayan gwaji, yana da $3.99/mo ba tare da ɗaukar nauyi na dogon lokaci ba. Babu matakin kyauta—mun yi imani masu motsa jiki sun cancanci cikakken nazari ba tare da kulle fasali na sabani ba.
Shirye Ku Don Gwada SwimAnalytics?
Gwada yankunan horo masu tushen CSS, sTSS mai sarrafa kansa, da ma'aunin PMC mai rahusa waɗanda aka ƙera musamman don masu iyo.
Fara Gwajin Kyauta Na Kwana 7Ba a buƙatar katin kuɗi • Soke kowane lokaci • iOS 16+